Thirteen felony counts. That is what Utah filed against the two founders of Kalshi, a prediction market, for running what the state calls illegal gambling. On Friday, the head of the US futures regulator said the states have gone too far — and warned that exchange bosses should not face prison over a legal argument.
Key points:
- CFTC Chair Michael Selig called the state cases "really egregious" and said founders should not face jail over whether event contracts count as gambling or derivatives.
- Utah charged Kalshi and its two co-founders with 13 felony counts in October, while Washington sued Arkansas on Thursday to block its case against the same platform.
- The fight now heads for the courts, with a Utah hearing on November 20 and a December 5 deadline for exchanges to drop state geofences.
Selig says a legal argument should not put founders in jail
Selig spoke at the Cantor Convergence conference on Friday, November 13, and he did not soften his words. "We're seeing states bring criminal charges, essentially trying to lock up founders and CEOs of these companies that are offering lawful products under a federal regime," he said. He called the state suits "really egregious" and stood by the CFTC's claim of "exclusive jurisdiction" over the event contracts that prediction markets trade.
His point was simple. "Somebody says it's gambling, somebody says it's a derivative," he said. "That's not something that should be at the risk of going to jail." He wants the question settled by the Supreme Court, not by one state after another. "I don't understand whether we're going to have every major CEO of an exchange locked up in a jail cell in Utah, or if we can just go to the Supreme Court and hash this thing out on the merits," he said. "I am concerned that some of the states are getting very aggressive," he added. "We'll continue to defend our jurisdiction."
Read also: What Are Prediction Markets? A Beginner's Guide
Utah turned a turf fight into a criminal case
Utah moved first and hardest. On October 28, Attorney General Derek Brown filed criminal charges against Kalshi and its two co-founders, chief executive Tarek Mansour and chief operating officer Luana Lopes Lara. The 13 felony counts followed undercover agents placing wagers on sports events through the platform in September. The CFTC had already sued Utah on October 26, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act of 1936 and the Constitution's Commerce Clause give it sole say over commodity derivatives, including event contracts. A hearing on the federal bid to stop Utah's cases is set for November 20.
Washington hit back in court the same week
The federal answer came fast. On Thursday, November 12, the Justice Department and the CFTC sued Arkansas Attorney General Tim Griffin in federal court in the Eastern District of Arkansas, asking a judge to block his case against Kalshi. Griffin had sued Kalshi on November 4, saying the platform ran an illegal gambling operation in the state. The federal suit, USA v. State of Arkansas, also asks the court to stop future state actions against CFTC-regulated prediction markets. Kalshi itself is not a party to the federal case.
The same day, Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill sued Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood and Coinbase. That makes roughly a dozen states and cities now in open dispute with the CFTC over event contracts. Since April, the CFTC has brought preemption actions in Arizona, Connecticut, Illinois, Kentucky, Minnesota, New Mexico, New York, Rhode Island and Wisconsin, and courts have granted preliminary injunctions against Arizona, Illinois and Minnesota. In July, the CFTC used emergency powers to order Kalshi to honor trades in Michigan, even though a court there had ordered the other way. Three California tribes also won a preliminary injunction on November 4 blocking Kalshi from offering sports contracts on tribal lands.
The geofence deadline is now the next test
On November 5, the CFTC issued interpretive guidance telling federally registered exchanges to drop domestic geographic restrictions within 30 days, or explain to its Division of Market Oversight why they cannot. The guidance, built on the impartial-access rule for designated contract markets, says a national market cannot be carved up state by state. The 30-day clock runs to about December 5. The catch is plain: State court orders in Michigan and Nevada still tell Kalshi to keep some users blocked, so the platforms sit between a federal regulator telling them to open the gates and state courts telling them to keep them shut. Senator Adam Schiff attacked the guidance on November 6, calling it the agency's "most egregious attempt yet to undermine state law" and accusing Selig of being "captured by the industry."
My own read is that the criminal charges changed this fight. A civil fine is a cost of doing business. Thirteen felony counts against named founders is a message — and the CFTC answered it with lawsuits of its own.
This is not just a fight about sports bets
The easy mistake is to call prediction markets sports betting with a finance label. The numbers say the market is much bigger than that. Combined monthly volume on Kalshi and Polymarket rose from under $5 billion in September 2025 to about $24 billion in April 2026, and the US midterm elections drove more than $3 billion in volume across the two platforms. Kalshi was valued at $22 billion in March, and Polymarket has been in talks for a valuation near $15 billion. Those are reported figures from private funding rounds, not audited facts, so treat them as a sign of size, not a precise count. Traders use these markets for elections, economics, crypto prices and sports — and the CFTC's point is that the contracts are derivatives under federal law, which is why it claims sole jurisdiction.
What traders should watch next
Three dates matter now. November 20 brings the Utah hearing on the CFTC's bid to stop the criminal cases. December 5 is the end of the 30-day geofencing window, when exchanges must show they dropped state blocks or explain why they cannot. December 7 is the reported date for Kalshi's Supreme Court response. Watch whether the platforms actually drop their geofences, and whether a federal judge backs the CFTC's claim that federal law overrides state gambling rules. If the CFTC wins, US traders get one national market. If the states win, access stays a patchwork, and platforms may pull products state by state. For now, nothing changes for users this week, but the legal ground under prediction markets is moving fast, and the next court ruling will set the direction.
Read also: Warren to Chair Senate Banking in January, Targets Prediction Markets and Trump Crypto
About the author: Muhammad Irfan is the founder and editor of BitByLine. He writes crypto news and beginner guides in simple, everyday language, so readers without a finance background can follow along. Read more about the editor.
This is news, not financial advice. BitByLine never tells you to buy or sell crypto — that decision is yours, and the risk is yours too. Do your own research before you buy or sell anything. Read our full Disclaimer.
Sources: The Block, Crypto Briefing, CEI, NextPredict, MacroOdds, and the CFTC's November 5 interpretive guidance on impartial access.

Comments
Post a Comment
We love hearing from our readers! Share your thoughts, questions, or corrections below — please keep it respectful and on topic.